Working on my second attempt at a low-plastic stacking solution for the cheap "non-stackable" NOJIG bins from IKEA. This time it's a net that hooks over the edges of the bin. Hoping it's a bit more stable than my previous corner support solution.
More work will certainly be needed to reduce the plastic consumption, but it's a decent start!
The wires ended up not working very well - however, they did inspire a slightly different solution. Instead of wires, I now fill up the slots with a solid layer - but only a *single* layer, instead of the full height, which is just enough to provide extra rigidity.
I've also slightly increased the thickness of the whole thing again, because it was bending at the hooks too much, risking breakage under weight. I've also modified the end hooks a bit; they are now actually hook-shaped, and thinner in some non-critical places.
The end result is a plastic cost of 1.65 meters; only slightly higher than the empty-slot version, which was about 1.55 meters. The original design was 3 meters!
The design seems about perfect now; the hooks only engage with the rim of the bin once it's under weight and the hooks are pulled towards it, whereas without weight there's enough margin that you can take off the whole net without getting stuck on that rim.
And it's working quite well with some stuff stacked on top of it! And a lot more stable than my previous corner design :)
(The intention for this design is to allow stacking bins, of course, but stacking the box of bits directly on top of it makes it more obviously visible how it works!)
The slicer view makes it pretty visible where it's getting its strength from!
I'll have to think about how to construct an impact testing rig, to figure out exactly *how* strong this design is. Should be receiving some aluminium profiles (for a different project) soon, can probably use those for this?
So far I have 5 bins stacked on top of each other on my desk, with the topmost bin containing a few heavy boxes of screwdriver and drill bits. The tower still seems perfectly stable! And I'm not seeing any kind of wear or fatigue marks on any of the stacking nets.
(These are printed in crappy PLA, to be clear, so I'm testing pretty much the worst case in terms of mechanical strength, relying entirely on the design)
Did the math, and after the plastic use optimization, the stacking nets for the 15x20cm bins cost me 6 cents each in filament cost. The bins themselves cost 49 cents each.
@joepie91 i am extremely sceptical that will significantly add to the strength
@bananas Probably not significantly, but it doesn't need to be significant :)
@joepie91 like i think saving the material would be better, especially considering how easy to break they look
@joepie91 oh btw, your languages that work sorta like js thing, did anyone mention lua yet? i've been writing some the last few days for reasons.
@bananas It indeed ended up not working, but for an unexpected reason - the wire warped too much!
@joepie91 i must admit i expected that.
@joepie91 I don't believe those wires do anything for strength. They're also likely the first to go out and possibly take a bit of the rest of the structure out with them.
If we're 3D-printing with filament anyway, why not add a few wires for strength? They cost barely any plastic!